Emma Perry has dropped the kind of claim that stops a fandom mid-scroll. According to a report published on October 29, the 90 Day: Hunt for Love star alleges that co-star Kara Bass once asked Jamal Menzies for a threesome. The allegation is unconfirmed, and as of writing, neither Kara nor Jamal has publicly addressed this specific claim. Within hours, the fandom had picked sides.
The claim did not come from nowhere. Emma and Kara have clashed at the Puerto Rico resort since early in Season 2: Kara called Emma a “psycho” for breaking down over Jamal, and Emma fired back with “Girl, let’s cut the bullshit,” calling Kara insecure. The new allegation pours fuel onto that feud.
What Emma Actually Claimed — and What Is Still Unconfirmed
According to reports, Emma claims she went through Jamal’s phone and found a text connected to the allegation, referring to Jamal and newcomer Ericka. The report also notes that Kalani Faagata previously questioned whether Kara and Jamal might have hooked up before the retreat. That was a question, not a confirmation — and it remains one.
The line that matters: Emma herself has previously confirmed that she and Jamal hooked up before the resort. What remains unconfirmed is the threesome ask itself. No message has been published, and no confirmation has come from Kara, Jamal, or TLC, according to the report. What follows is an argument about an allegation, not a verdict on it.
Team Believe Emma: Why Some Fans Say the Pieces Fit
The Believe Emma camp says the resort drama reads differently against what is already on the record. Emma and Jamal’s pre-show hookup is confirmed by Emma herself, so supporters say a second pre-show entanglement is not the leap skeptics claim. On this reading, Kara’s repeated public criticism of Emma looks less like a neutral reaction and more like someone with her own stake in the Jamal story.
Supporters also point to the detail: a phone, a text, a name. Vague rumors are easy to invent, they argue, while a claim this specific invites checking — and Emma made it anyway. Per the report, Reddit fans are already curious whether it could reshape resort relationships, and some believe it might be possible.
YOU MAY LIKESTOP Sharing That Viral Post: The Cruel Jenny Slatten Death Hoax Debunked — She’s Alive and Still FightingTeam Kara’s Being Smeared: Why Others Call Foul
The other camp is not buying it, and its case starts with the missing evidence. No message has been shown, no second source has confirmed the ask, and the claim surfaced mid-feud, just after the two women traded insults on camera and online. To skeptics, that timing alone is reason to pause: an unproven allegation landing right after a fight looks like retaliation dressed up as revelation.
They also note that Kalani’s question is being treated online as if it were proof, when it was only ever a question. Turning a “did they?” into a “they did” is how an unconfirmed rumor hardens into fandom fact, skeptics argue — and Emma’s admission that she went through Jamal’s phone is, to some fans, a red flag about how the information was obtained.
The One Person Who Could Settle It — and Hasn’t Yet
Both camps are waiting on the same person: Jamal. The alleged ask was reportedly made to him, and the alleged text was reportedly on his phone. A clear statement from him — or from Kara — would change this story overnight. Until either speaks, this is a story with one named source and two silent principals, and that silence is neither confession nor denial.
So, where do you stand: Team Believe Emma, or Team Kara’s Being Smeared? And what would it actually take to change your mind: a statement from Jamal, receipts, or nothing at all? Drop your team in the comments, and tell us what proof, if any, would settle it for you.
