One year ago, Amy Slaton married Brian Lovvorn on Halloween in a haunted tavern, and plenty of viewers wondered out loud whether it was all happening too fast. On Friday, October 31, 2026, Amy answered them the only way that really counts: with a quiet, happy, gloriously ordinary anniversary.
“Had a very great 1st anniversary!!” Amy wrote on Instagram, and the photos she shared told the whole story — no big party, no production, just a family being a family on the spookiest night of the year.
Breakfast, Trick-or-Treating and a Movie: How Year One Ended
Amy laid out the day herself. She and Brian started with a breakfast date while sons Gage, 5, and Glenn, 4, stayed with her niece Emily Combs. Then the couple picked the boys up and took them trick-or-treating, before finishing the evening at home with dinner and a movie.
It is the kind of anniversary that does not photograph like a fairy tale — and that is exactly why fans loved it. The costumes were pure Amy: Gage and Glenn dressed as yellow ducks, while Brian wore a jack-o’-lantern T-shirt. Halloween is not just a holiday in this family; it is the date on the marriage certificate.
The Carriage Photo That Tied It All Together
One anniversary picture stopped fans mid-scroll: the family posed on the white carriage from Amy and Brian’s “old-timey” wedding. The couple married on October 31, 2025, at Bardstown’s reportedly haunted Talbott Tavern.
Amy had already used the same carriage for her six-month post in April, when she called Brian her “safe place,” her “biggest supporter” and her “best friend.” Returning to it with Gage and Glenn in tow turned a wedding prop into a family tradition.
YOU MAY LIKEAmy Slaton Considers Breast Surgery — and Fans Are Split: “She Earned This” vs. “Her Body Is Beautiful Already”From a Haunted-House Proposal to “My Safe Place”
Here is the timeline the doubters keep quoting. Amy and Brian met at a concert in the park in 2024, and Brian proposed inside the padded room of a haunted house in Henderson, Kentucky, in winter 2024 — after only about five months of dating. They announced their engagement in May 2025 and married that Halloween in a Victorian-themed ceremony with ghost bridesmaids and a black tiara.
That speed is what split the fandom. Some fans said Amy was rushing into a second marriage after her divorce from Michael Halterman, Gage and Glenn’s father. Others said after years of putting everyone else first, Amy finally knew what she wanted.
The Detail Fans Keep Coming Back To: Tammy Wasn’t in the Wedding Party
There is one anniversary subplot fans cannot let go of, and it involves Amy’s sister. Amy chose her best friend Ollisha Davis as her maid of honor, and Tammy was not part of the wedding party — a detail that stung at the time, given how close the sisters’ story has always been.
Look at where the sisters stand now, though, and the symmetry is hard to miss. This season, Amy is the one standing beside Tammy as maid of honor while Tammy plans her own wedding to fiancée Andrea Dalton.
So, Did the Doubters Get It Wrong?
But consider what year one actually contained: a wedding that aired on the season 8 finale, a six-month tribute calling Brian the “calm in the storm,” and now a first anniversary of breakfast, ducks and a movie night at home.
The doubters said it was too fast. The supporters said Amy had finally found her person. One year in, the photos suggest the supporters have the stronger case. So, where do you stand: did Amy and Brian just prove the doubters wrong, or is one year still too soon to call it? Tell us in the comments — Team Bramy, or still not convinced?
