Before Chantel Everett and Pedro Jimeno said “I do” in 2016, her mother Karen had already hired a private investigator to dig into him. The suspicion was blunt: Pedro, a Dominican student she had met while teaching English there in 2015, was marrying her for a green card. Ten years later, both have moved on — and fans still cannot agree on whether Karen was right.
The Accusation: A Private Investigator and a K-1 Visa
Karen and Thomas Everett never hid their doubt. From the first season of 90 Day Fiancé, they treated Pedro as a suspect first and a son-in-law second — the private investigator was only the most famous example. The K-1 fiancé visa gave the suspicion its shape: Pedro had 90 days to marry after arriving in America, and the Everetts read that deadline as a motive. Pedro denied it every time. What nobody ever produced was proof.

Pedro’s Case: Ten Years in America, and He Never Left
Pedro filed for divorce in May 2022, and the marriage ended — but he did not leave. Four years after the split, he still lives and works in Georgia, where he built a real estate career. On June 6, 2026, he proposed to Valentina Malagon, a Colombian psychologist, on a beach in Oahu, Hawaii, under a heart-shaped arch of red roses. He announced the engagement on June 23 and told PEOPLE that with Valentina, he had learned that “peace has a name” — and that he will marry her with or without his mother Lidia’s blessing. His supporters ask: if the green card was the whole plan, why is he still in Georgia a decade later, proposing on a Hawaiian beach?

Chantel’s Case: “Prime Years” and a Second Wedding
Chantel’s side of the ledger looks very different. In 2024 she said Pedro had taken her “prime years” — shorthand for everything the marriage cost her. Then she rebuilt it all in public: a career as a nurse injector in Sandy Springs, a coming-out on 90 Day: Hunt for Love in August 2025, and a second wedding on October 17, 2026, when she married Ashley Bowen at Fountainview Mansion in Auburn, Alabama, in front of about 60 guests, according to PEOPLE. The couple left by helicopter for a surprise honeymoon in Cancun that Ashley had booked in secret. Her supporters read it as an answer: Pedro filed first and moved on fast, while Chantel had to rebuild from the wreckage. The fight between the two families who fought over them never really ended.
The One Fact Neither Side Can Dodge
Here is the awkward truth: both readings fit the same facts. No document, no confession, no leak has ever shown that Pedro married Chantel for immigration papers — the accusation stayed a suspicion for all ten years. And staying proves nothing by itself either: Georgia is where his career is, where his sister Nicole lives, and where the life he built is. The evidence convicts nobody, and it clears nobody. That is exactly why the argument has survived the marriage itself.
So Was Karen Right?
On the evidence available in November 2026, the honest verdict is “unproven” — maybe permanently so. Chantel is married. Pedro is engaged. But one line cuts through it: Pedro is still in Georgia, still building, still waiting on a wedding date of his own — while the woman he was accused of using just married someone else in front of 60 witnesses and a helicopter.
YOU MAY LIKEKaren and Thomas Everett: The Marriage That Survived Every Chantel Storm — and the One Wedding Question LeftTen years after a classroom in the Dominican Republic, do you believe Karen’s private investigator was protecting her daughter — or poisoning a marriage that might have survived without him?
More The Family Chantel drama
The Family ChantelOne Month After ‘I Do’: Chantel and Ashley’s First 32 Days as Wives
The Family ChantelFrom Premiere to Helicopter Exit: The Family Chantel’s 7-Year Timeline — and the One Date TLC Still Hasn’t Set
The Family Chantel31 Days a Wife: Everything We Know About Chantel Everett’s Life After Ashley



