On December 26, 2025, Winter Everett posted a clip of herself and her husband David Hodgson holding a sonogram, both wearing matching Mom and Dad caps. “The best Christmas gift wasn’t under the tree this year… it’s been growing in my heart,” she wrote, calling the baby their “2026 miracle.” Ten months later, her older sister Chantel married Ashley Bowen in Alabama. Two sisters, two brand-new chapters — and one loud argument. Whose baby comes first?
Is Winter Really About to Become a Mom First?
Winter is the only sister with a due date on the horizon, even if she has never shared it publicly. She announced the pregnancy on December 26, 2025, and has posted no due date or gender reveal since, according to reports. She married David Hodgson in May 2025, after confirming their engagement that March. Winter’s 2026 miracle would be the first grandchild the Everett family has announced publicly, and that alone puts her ahead in any race.
Does Chantel Even Want a Baby With Ashley?
Chantel married Ashley Bowen on October 17, 2026, at Fountainview Mansion in Auburn, Alabama, in front of about 60 guests, according to PEOPLE. She told the magazine that their next chapter is about “enjoying life as a married couple and giving ourselves room to dream together.” There is no baby announcement and no rush in her words. But Chantel’s history makes the question impossible to ignore. In 2024, she said her ex-husband Pedro Jimeno had taken her prime years, explaining that she had wanted children but kept delaying motherhood over travel and a busy schedule, according to ScreenRant. Now she is a wife again, working as a nurse injector in Sandy Springs, Georgia, married to the woman she chose herself. One side of the fandom says a baby is the obvious next chapter; the other says she just got her freedom back after a decade of family war, and diapers can wait — and her first month as a wife already had a helicopter exit and a secret honeymoon.
What Would Karen Say? The Mom in the Middle
No Everett debate is complete without Karen Everett, and her record on Ashley is a plot twist of its own. At the 90 Day: Hunt for Love Tell All, Karen accused Ashley of using her daughter, calling her a “clout chaser.” But she also drew a line fans still quote: “I am not upset about Chantel being with a woman; I just don’t want her to get hurt at the end of the day.” Then Chantel asked the question that mattered — “How would you feel if it was me and Ashley getting married?” — and Karen answered, “I would come to the wedding.” She did. Karen has said nothing publicly about grandbabies from either daughter, and that silence is doing a lot of work right now.
Who Set This Whole Thing in Motion? Ask River
None of this happens without River Everett. Chantel met Ashley through River at one of his birthday parties, and Ashley was friends with her brothers before she ever became her wife. He also promised fans the show itself would return, telling them in November 2025 that The Family Chantel was coming back in July 2026. July came and went in silence, and TLC has still announced nothing — but River’s claim that the show is coming back keeps getting new life every time the family gives fans something to argue about.
So Who Wins the Baby Race — and Would TLC Even Film It?
On the calendar, Winter wins — she is already expecting, and Chantel has announced nothing. But the debate is not really about a due date. Chantel spent ten years, a divorce, and a coming-out season getting to a marriage she chose, and her fans argue that is the bigger win no matter what Winter’s sonogram says. Winter’s fans answer that a baby on the way beats a wedding already over. As for the cameras, nobody has confirmed anything: TLC has announced no new season, though the cast was reportedly spotted filming in downtown Atlanta before the wedding.
YOU MAY LIKEKaren and Thomas Everett: The Marriage That Survived Every Chantel Storm — and the One Wedding Question LeftWinter is already expecting, and Chantel is one month into the marriage she waited a decade to reach. So here is the question splitting the fandom: should Chantel and Ashley try for a baby next to keep up with Winter, or should Chantel enjoy the marriage she fought so hard for before thinking about diapers? Team Winter or Team Chantel — whose timeline would you follow?
More The Family Chantel drama
The Family ChantelThe Divorce, Date by Date: Chantel & Pedro’s Split From Separation to Final Papers
The Family ChantelTeam Pedro vs. Team Chantel: Who Was Right About the Divorce? Fans Still Split 4 Years Later
The Family Chantel29 Days a Wife: Everything We Know About Chantel & Ashley’s Married Life
