TRENDING Jenna Johnson’s Reception Dress Came Down to a Midnight Call to ParisShe Lost Her Mom and Her Sister to a ‘Cult’ — Carrie Brown Finally Tells Her Side25 Hours, $12 an Hour, 25 Percent: Mama G’s Rule for Jose — and the Month It Ended
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › I Love a Mama's Boy
I Love a Mama's Boy

5 Mama’s Boys Most Likely to Finally Choose Love Over Mom — Ranked

5 Mama’s Boys Most Likely to Finally Choose Love Over Mom — Ranked

Lori Boatright — the mom Chase still has not chosen against. (TLC)

Matt McAdams posted a photo of himself, his mother Kelly and his girlfriend Devon — all three smiling in the same frame — and wrote, “This story is just beginning!” Kelly once admitted she did not want to “share” Matt at all. Now, according to Matt, she is “ready for the ride.” So which son is actually most likely to finally choose his partner over his mom? We ranked all five, from the longest shot to the safest bet.

No. 5 — Shahid: Still Asking Mom What Ring He Can Afford

Shahid and Nylah at a jewelry counter on I Love a Mama's Boy Season 4
Shahid and Nylah ring shopping — with Mom’s $25 budget hanging over the whole trip. (TLC)

Shahid has the steepest hill to climb. His mother Dia judged his girlfriend Nylah the moment they met — and never revised it. Worse, Shahid still could not buy an engagement ring without his mother’s budget: twenty-five dollars, per the show. Ring shopping with Mom in the room is not a proposal plan, it is a permission slip. That is why he sits at the bottom — and the 2026 couples scorecard shows how little has moved for the Season 4 couples since the finale.

No. 4 — Mike: The One-Way Ticket He Never Used

Mike Boornazian once held the whole story in his hands: a one-way ticket to Los Angeles, a girlfriend in Stephanie who had waited three years, and a mother in Liz who still set his birthday gift budget. He never used the ticket. They were still together in 2022 — but according to reports from 2024, they have since split. If a man cannot leave when he is literally holding the ticket, what would make him leave now?

No. 3 — Chase: Caught Between the Middle of the Bed and the Altar

Natasha reacts with shock on I Love a Mama's Boy Season 4
Natasha’s face says what Chase will not: the middle of the bed is not a plan. (TLC)

Chase Tyson is the most torn man on this list. Lori Boatright announced she was “the eyes and ears for Chase,” crashed his fiancée Natasha’s bridal fitting, and asked — in the Season 4 mid-season trailer — whether Chase would want his mother to sleep in the middle of the bed. Two years after the November 18, 2024 finale, there is still no wedding, no breakup and no public update on where Chase and Natasha stand. He has chosen the middle — and the middle is exactly where Lori wants him.

No. 2 — Jason: Six Years Engaged, Still Waiting on a Wedding

Jason McClain has lasted longer than anyone else here, and that is precisely the problem. He and Justina have a daughter, a home and an engagement dating back to Season 1 in 2020 — but six years later, Justina’s bio still reads “Fiancé to @jasonmcclay” and there is still no wedding. Annette tried to plan the whole thing herself: Las Vegas, a red tux, a large say. Justina wanted a summer camp wedding and a gray suit, and six years of waiting later she still has not had it. Surviving is not choosing.

No. 1 — Matt: The Only Mom Who Switched Sides

Matt McAdams tops this ranking for one reason: he is the only son whose mother already moved. Kelly’s record was brutal — the graveyard birthday trip, the crashed dates, the Kim years. Yet this fall, Kelly sat down for The Sarah Fraser Show podcast alongside Matt and Devon, all three together. Kelly is the only mom who actually changed her mind — and a son does not have to fight his mother when his mother has already joined his side. According to reports, Season 5 remains unconfirmed, 729 days after the Season 4 finale. But if TLC ever calls, Matt is the only mama’s boy walking in with Mom already on Team Girlfriend.

The Women Who Walked Away: 4 Exes Who Escaped I Love a Mama’s BoyYOU MAY LIKEThe Women Who Walked Away: 4 Exes Who Escaped I Love a Mama’s Boy

Kelly proved a mother can change her mind. The other four proved how rare that is. So who is your money on: Matt, the only son whose mom already switched sides — or Jason, who has waited six years for a wedding his mother tried to plan for him? And if you were Natasha, would you still be waiting on Chase two years after the finale?

Keep reading

More I Love a Mama's Boy drama

I Love a Mama's Boy

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
LH
Lauren Hayes

Lauren covers My Big Fat Fabulous Life, I Am Shauna Rae, OutDaughtered, Doubling Down with the Derricos, I Love a Mama's Boy, Unexpected and Welcome to Plathville for Remote & Tea — cast updates, recaps and fan debates.

More from I Love a Mama's Boy

See more ›