TRENDING The Bride Who Said No to White and Yes to a Red Pnina TornaiThe Last Resort Scoreboard: 3 of 17 Couples Still Together — Is the Retreat Cursed, or Just Honest TV?New Boyfriends, Broken Engagements and a Secret Wedding: Where Unexpected’s Youngest Moms Stand Now
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › 1000-Lb Sisters
1000-Lb Sisters

1,200 Upvotes Say Andrea Is ‘Ruining the Show’ — the 452 Downvotes Tell Another Story

1,200 Upvotes Say Andrea Is ‘Ruining the Show’ — the 452 Downvotes Tell Another Story

Tammy Slaton. The Reddit thread about her fiancée has 1,200 upvotes — and 452 downvotes. (Still: TLC)

The thread went up on November 17 with a title that left no room for doubt: “Andrea ruining the show.” By the next morning, it had collected about 1,200 upvotes — and 452 downvotes. One thread, two verdicts, 23 days before Tammy Slaton’s wedding.

The Post That Called Season 9 “a MESS”

The opening poster did not hedge. Andrea Dalton’s alleged lies and alleged use of a racial slur, the post argued, spelled “the downfall of the show.” Season 9 was “a MESS,” the poster wrote — “arguing and crying” — and the post ended with one flat sentence: “I will no longer be watching.”

The timing explains the heat. Season 9 opened September 1 with Tammy’s first horseback ride and Andrea’s proposal, and it closed on November 10 with “Down in Pounds Hollow” — an hour that named Andrea’s health scare with a single word, “maybe tumor,” and no confirmed diagnosis. The supersized cut on November 15 added no answer. The thread landed two days later, with the finale’s loose ends still hanging and the slur allegation fresh from a November 16 Reddit post.

The 452 Downvotes Have Their Own Argument

Andrea Dalton in a grey shirt talking with Tammy Slaton at a table
Andrea Dalton. The thread’s replies split three ways over her alleged words — intent, context, and blame. (Still: TLC)

But the thread’s own replies refused to agree. Stardustkitty98 called the alleged language unsurprising and speculated cast members censor themselves for the cameras. Disastrous-You9086 rejected blaming a rural Southern background, saying Andrea used the word because she was racist. Twist-the-bones argued immaturity does not excuse adults using racial slurs.

Read together, the replies are not a defense of Andrea — they are a fandom split three ways over intent, context, and blame. Some debated whether Andrea could even be removed without ending the show: she is now the center of Tammy’s storyline, and Tammy’s December 12 wedding is its unfinished business. TV Season & Spoilers, reporting the backlash on November 18, put it plainly: the “downfall” claim remains fan opinion, not evidence of a series crisis.

The Next Morning, “Andrea’s Cousins Live”

The argument did not cool overnight. On November 18, a second discussion, “Andrea’s cousins live,” took up the slur allegation again and debated whether context could excuse it. Behind both threads sits a week of claims that arrived faster than anyone could check: alleged screenshots from Andrea’s cousin, posted November 15, accusing Andrea of having “TERRORIZED my Mamaw,” and her ex’s claims — kidney failure around 2021, shared money spent on alcohol and cannabis, harassment of the ex’s grandmother.

Amy Slaton’s 1st Anniversary Photos Just Answered the Question Everyone Asked About BrianYOU MAY LIKEAmy Slaton’s 1st Anniversary Photos Just Answered the Question Everyone Asked About Brian

Andrea answered on Facebook on November 16: “Y’all, I have a crazy ex trying to mess my name up because she found out I was getting married.” She added that she “didn’t get along with dad’s side of the family.” She did not address the kidney and money allegations — and fans noticed, linking the kidney claim to the questioned brain-tumor storyline and the six-month prognosis Andrea reportedly mentioned to Amy. The finale’s “maybe” is still the only word anyone has.

What “Ruining the Show” Would Actually Take

Chris Combs in a red sweatshirt leaning in during a conversation
Chris Combs. His fear is that Tammy could relive the pain of losing her late husband Caleb Willingham. (Still: TLC)

The thread’s loudest predictions go further: TLC could remove Andrea, Tammy could leave, or the show could be canceled — fans have speculated all three. All three remain predictions. Season 9 ranked No. 8 on HBO Max’s U.S. top 10 on November 4, and no Season 10 renewal — or cancellation — has been announced.

Underneath the vote count sit the human stakes. Tammy’s December 12 wedding is 23 days away, and her brother Chris Combs’ fear — that she could relive the pain of losing her late husband Caleb Willingham, who died in July 2023 — is the part no vote count can settle. A thread can vote on whether Andrea is ruining a show. It cannot vote on whether Tammy walks down the aisle.

So here is the question, for the 1,200 and the 452 alike: on December 12, when Tammy walks down the aisle toward Andrea, will you be watching a wedding — or waiting for a Reddit thread to be proven right?

Keep reading

More 1000-Lb Sisters drama

1000-Lb Sisters

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
KB
Katie Brennan

Katie covers Sister Wives, 1000-Lb Sisters and 7 Little Johnstons for Remote & Tea — cast updates, family news and where-are-they-now stories.

More from 1000-Lb Sisters

See more ›