“Please STOP getting animals!!!!!!!!!!!!” That comment, posted under the news that Trent and Amber Johnston have two new puppies, has eleven exclamation points. Half the fandom agrees. The other half thinks a family that has filmed with dogs for a decade deserves the benefit of the doubt. Season 18 is barely a week old, and the Johnstons already have their first real fight. It is about two puppies named Birdie and Moki.
Two Puppies Walk Into Season 18 — So Why Are Fans Furious?
On paper, the puppies are the easiest storyline in the world: two puppies, a big family house, instant cute television. But the reaction, reported by TV Spoiler News on November 20, was not celebration. Fans say this family has a pattern: animals arrive on camera, then sooner or later they are gone.
Jesse, Louie and Miller: What Do Fans Say Actually Happened?

Start with Jesse: fans recall Trent and Amber gave up an elderly chocolate Lab kept for years, and Jesse died shortly after, according to fan accounts. “Yes they got rid of Jesse like he was an old piece of furniture,” one viewer wrote. Then Louie, the French bulldog: Amber has said he did not adjust well, so they rehomed him. And Miller, fans recall, got seriously ill under Liz and Brice’s care. None of this is a verdict — but for the critics, Birdie and Moki are just the next chapter of a story they have seen end badly.
Wait — Where Are the Chickens?
The counter-argument writes itself: animals get sick, accidents happen, and rehoming a dog that does not fit is sometimes the responsible choice. But the critics have a follow-up that is harder to laugh off. “Where are the chickens? She had to have those damn chickens when they were so busy doing everything else related to the wedding just why,” one viewer asked. The chickens arrived around Liz and Brice’s wedding season — then, like Louie and Jesse, faded from the story without an ending. For Team Skeptical, that is the proof: the issue is a habit, not one bad week. For Team Give Them a Chance, the chickens prove nothing at all.
Is Anna Quietly the Family’s Best Pet Parent?
Here is the twist that makes this fight sting: the person fans hold up as the good example is Anna. “I’m glad Anna took Cruiser,” one commenter wrote, adding that Anna seems to properly care for her dogs. Anna left the show after Season 16 and does not appear in Season 18, according to reports — yet the daughter whose relationship with her parents fractured on camera is now, to a loud part of the fandom, the one who got the pet thing right. Even their defenders admit the optics are rough.
Two More Fights to Settle Before Episode 2

The puppy fight is the loudest, but not the only argument fans carry into Tuesday. Jonah is 25, seven years into his relationship with Ashley, and Trent and Amber have openly questioned why seven years brought no progress toward marriage — that is the seven-year question hanging over Jonah and Ashley. Then Emma, 21, answered whether she wants a boyfriend with one word: “Yes.” Now Emma’s one-word yes to dating has Ashley and Allie in matchmaker mode. Episode 2 airs Tuesday, November 24, at 9 p.m. ET/PT — and if the premiere-week timeline is any guide, the dogs will not be the only thing fans argue about on Wednesday morning.
YOU MAY LIKEEverything We Know About 7 Little Johnstons Season 18 — Wedding Bells, New Homes, and One Big Question MarkSo pick your side before Tuesday night. Birdie and Moki are here, the cameras are rolling: should Trent and Amber spend this season proving the doubters wrong — or was bringing home two more dogs, after Jesse, the one decision this family should have skipped? Tell us where you stand.







