Alex Johnston is 21. He has already given Allie Smith a promise ring and told the cameras he hopes to get engaged next year. His older brother Jonah is 25 — and after seven years with Ashley, he has not even moved out of his parents’ house. That gap is the fight splitting the 7 Little Johnstons fandom, and the Season 18 premiere put it on screen, with Trent and Amber openly asking why seven years brought no progress toward marriage or moving in, according to The Ashley’s Reality Roundup. So here is the question, asked straight: should Jonah propose to Ashley this year — or should Ashley walk away?
Team Propose: Seven Years Has Earned a Ring
Start with what Ashley has already survived. She was there through the Delta 8 scare, the move back home, and his parents doubting the relationship would last. She stayed. And now she is doing the show’s work for free — teaming up with Allie to play matchmaker for Emma while her own future stays blank. Meanwhile Liz married Brice Bolden in November 2025 and is already a mom of two. The Propose camp says the math is simple: after seven years without an answer, the ring is not a rush — it is overdue.
Team Walk Away: A Ring Fixes Nothing

Now the other side, and it is not cruel — it is practical. Jonah still sleeps under his parents’ roof, with no move-out plan. A proposal from that address is a photo op, not a marriage: where would the couple even live? Jonah graded the relationship himself on August 16, 2022, telling the cameras he and Ashley had been dating a little over three years and “it could be better.” Four years on, only the number has changed. Jonah landed last in the premiere power rankings for exactly this reason — same question, same non-answer. Team Walk Away says a ring is no substitute for a life: walk away, set the deadline, and let Jonah prove the marriage can stand on its own.
The Little Brother Problem Nobody Can Dodge

Here is what makes the debate impossible to park until next season: Alex is not waiting. The 21-year-old has a promise ring already given, a plan said out loud to get engaged next year, and a future mapped around Allie’s family farm. Jonah, meanwhile, has said his younger brother should not marry before him, according to TV Season & Spoilers. So the wedding race between the brothers is real now. If Alex proposes next year and Jonah still has not, the family faces a real choice: honor the older-brother-first rule, or celebrate the couple that is actually ready?
What Ashley Actually Gets Out of Season 18
Look past the romance at the contract. TLC has not announced Ashley as a main cast member, and nothing in the trailer suggests that changes. One fan theory says a wedding could bring her into the cast full time — speculation, not a network announcement. What is real is the work: Ashley is on screen helping Emma, 21, take her first steps into dating — Emma answered the trailer’s boyfriend question with a single word, “Yes” — while Ashley’s own seven-year relationship gets questioned at the dinner table. The show gets her labor. She gets the waiting room.
Episode 2 airs Tuesday, November 24, at 9 p.m. ET/PT. So declare it now: are you Team Propose — Jonah should put a ring on Ashley’s finger before Alex laps him — or Team Walk Away — Ashley should pack up her patience and go until Jonah has his own front door? No middle ground. Pick a side.
YOU MAY LIKEEverything We Know About 7 Little Johnstons Season 18 — Wedding Bells, New Homes, and One Big Question Mark






