“Wow just post this so Jessica can see it knowing how many times you made her go for IVF and it didnt work” — that comment under Isaiah Martin’s baby photos, which goes on to invoke the death of Jessica’s father, is the angriest version of a question splitting MBFFL fans in two. In August, about two months after the divorce was finalized, Isaiah posted photos holding a newborn baby boy, captioned “Changed instantly. My twin,” with a blue heart. The baby’s mother appears to be Deojanae, 28, a former track star who called the baby “My Sweetest Little Love, My Greatest Blessing.” One post turned a 2022 TV wedding into a court file — and a comment fight.
The timing is strange: Season 14 just premiered, with Whitney Way Thore’s engagement as its focus — while her former trainer’s marriage ends off camera, in court records. Fans are doing math on dates, and the math is what split them.
April 16, 2022 to June 10, 2026: The Marriage in Dates
Jessica Powell, Whitney’s trainer, married Isaiah Martin on April 16, 2022, with the ceremony filmed for Season 10. Fans at the time: “I really love her and Isaiah together,” one wrote. Court records obtained by Starcasm say the couple separated on or about March 16, 2025, and “continuously lived separate and apart” after that. Isaiah filed on April 9, 2026; Jessica was served but did not appear, and on June 10 a judge granted an absolute divorce.

“Changed Instantly. My Twin”: The August Photo
Two months after the divorce was finalized, Isaiah’s Instagram changed the story. In August, he posted photos holding a newborn baby boy — “Changed instantly. My twin,” he wrote, with a blue heart. (“Twin” reads as a lookalike — both reports describe one baby boy, not twins.) The baby’s mother appears to be Deojanae, who shared the baby’s photos with Isaiah. That blank space is where the fandom’s fight started.
Camp One: “A Slap in the Face”
The first camp reads the dates and sees a betrayal. A baby photographed in August was conceived months earlier, while Isaiah and Jessica were still legally married — separated, but married on paper. That timing lands cruelly against what fans remember Jessica enduring on the show: round after round of failed IVF, and her father’s death. To this camp, posting the baby two months after the divorce was final was no new beginning — it was a message Jessica could not miss.
Camp Two: “They’d Been Apart Since March 2025”
The second camp reads the same dates and disagrees. Separated since March 16, 2025 — sixteen months before the baby photos — the marriage was over in every way but paperwork, they argue, and a man apart from his wife that long is free to build a new life. In this reading, the baby is not a betrayal but a beginning. The anger, they say, mistakes the judge’s date for the marriage’s real end.
YOU MAY LIKE“Grow Up and Realize What Your Options Are”: Whitney Thore’s Ex Lennie Just Said What No One Dares to SayThe Question Nobody Can Answer Yet: Where Does Whitney Stand?
One more silence hangs over this, and it belongs to Whitney Way Thore. It is unclear if Jessica and Whitney are still close — fans believe the two may have had a falling out, and neither has said so publicly.

Meanwhile, Whitney is engaged, her new romance the focus of the season now airing — one woman’s love story is the show’s centerpiece while the other woman’s marriage ends in court records and an Instagram post. So the question the comments cannot settle: the baby was photographed in August, conceived while Isaiah and Jessica were still legally husband and wife — does sixteen months of separation make that fair, or does the timing make it a betrayal no separation can excuse? And if Jessica ever tells her side, will Whitney be standing beside her when she does?
More My Big Fat Fabulous Life drama
My Big Fat Fabulous Life5 People Who Hold Whitney and Jake’s Engagement in Their Hands, Ranked
My Big Fat Fabulous LifeFans Have 5 Theories About Whitney’s Stepmom Era — and One Changes Everything
My Big Fat Fabulous LifeDid Isaiah Post His Baby Boy to Hurt Jessica? The Reddit Theory Dividing MBFFL Fans



