On November 21, a Reddit user put into words what a lot of MBFFL fans had been thinking since August: Isaiah Martin did not just post a photo of his newborn son — he posted it, the theory goes, so Jessica Powell would see it. A sad split had become a question about intent.
Isaiah filed for divorce on April 9, 2026, citing separation on “or about March 16, 2025.” On June 10, a court granted him an absolute divorce after Jessica was served but did not appear. About two months later, he shared photos holding a newborn boy — his child with a new partner, not Jessica’s. And the divorce was finalized in June, a timeline fans had already fought over.
November 21: The Theory That Turned a Baby Photo Into a Weapon
The theory: Isaiah knew who would see that photo, and posted it anyway. The angriest version, now circulating across the fandom, reads: “Wow just post this so Jessica can see it knowing how many times you made her go for IVF and it didnt work” — before going on to invoke the death of her father. For this camp, the cruelty is not the baby. It is the audience. Jessica spent years on camera enduring failed IVF rounds while grieving her late father Will Powell, whose gym is where they met — and where he proposed. Posting a newborn to the same feed was, they argue, a message dressed up as a milestone.
August: Two Months After the Divorce, “My Twin”

In August 2026, about two months after the divorce was finalized, he shared photos cradling a newborn boy in a hospital blanket, captioned “Changed instantly” and “My twin,” with a blue heart. Twin here reads as a lookalike — reports describe one baby boy, not twins. The baby’s mother is believed to be Deojanae, according to reports based on a shared Instagram gallery; it is unconfirmed, and her profile is private. That gap is the whole argument.
The Other Side: Sixteen Months Apart Changes the Math

His defenders read the same dates and reach the opposite conclusion. The couple had been living apart since March 2025 — sixteen months before the baby photos appeared — the marriage already legally over. A new father posting his son, they say, is not a weapon; it is what new fathers do. The photos also went up in August, not the week the news broke — the outrage, in this reading, is three months late.
While the Comments Fight, Jessica Is Winning Trophies

Jessica has said nothing about the theory — her Instagram tells a very different story. She threw herself into competitive bodybuilding and won first place at the OCB Pro Yorton Cup Moment Figure championship, taking home a medal and a $6,000 cash prize. Days earlier, on November 18, Reddit buzzed over her new look — a black gown, tattoos and muscle — with fans saying they barely recognized her. Her supporters call it the loudest possible answer.
YOU MAY LIKE“Grow Up and Realize What Your Options Are”: Whitney Thore’s Ex Lennie Just Said What No One Dares to SayThe Silence Nobody Can Read
Two questions have no answer. The first is whether Jessica and Whitney Way Thore are even still close — fans believe the two may have had a falling out, and neither woman has clarified it while Season 14 rolls on. The second is what Jessica thinks of the baby photo — she has given no sign she plans to say. Whitney is engaged, the season is airing, and the woman at the center of it lets her medals do the talking.
So the question the comments cannot settle: if a baby arrives sixteen months after a separation, two months after a divorce, is posting him a betrayal, a right, or just a new dad oversharing — and if Jessica ever breaks her silence, should she address the photo at all, or keep letting the trophies speak?
More My Big Fat Fabulous Life drama
My Big Fat Fabulous LifeFans Have 5 Theories About Whitney’s Stepmom Era — and One Changes Everything
My Big Fat Fabulous LifeBecoming a Stepmom at 42: Everything We Know About Whitney, Jake, and His 12-Year-Old Daughter
My Big Fat Fabulous Life5 Season 14 Moments We’re Still Waiting For, Ranked — The IUI Secret Tops the List



