“I’m coming to the point where it’s either me or them.” David Woolley said it in a therapist’s office, on camera, in the Season 21 trailer — and he never named who “them” was. For sixteen years, Sister Wives had an obvious villain, and his name was Kody Brown. He is gone now. The show goes on without him. And the fandom is fighting harder than ever — only now nobody can agree on who the bad guy is.
Season 21 premiered October 4 without Kody and Robyn, and every storyline since has produced a new suspect. Here are the four names on the ballot.
Candidate No. 1: David Woolley — “It’s Either Me or Them”

David walked into Season 21 as the hero — the kind husband who treats Christine like a queen. Then the trailer showed him in therapy: “When you’re with me, you’re Christine Woolley, but it’s that other side, she becomes Christine Brown. I’m coming to the point where it’s either me or them.” In a preview obtained by Us Weekly, he said he was “tired” of conversations about her former family.
To one camp, it is a fair boundary — and David’s marriage fears are only getting louder. Christine agrees living in the past is unhealthy and credits therapy. To the other camp, it is a man who married a woman with 27 years of history and six children, then acted surprised the history came with her. Christine put it plainly: “I think polygamy made me who I am.”
Candidate No. 2: Robyn Brown — the Woman Who Said Nothing
Robyn’s case is built on sixteen years of television and zero words since. TLC announced on September 14 that she and Kody would not return. She has not explained the decision. Janelle told PEOPLE on November 2 that she learned about the exit by email and has not spoken to the couple since the family sold Coyote Pass.
One camp calls the silence a smart escape: no more confessionals dissecting her marriage in front of millions. The other calls it dodging the reckoning — she was the last wife standing, the one who got the legal marriage in 2014, and she walked away without answering for any of it. In January, Kody told her they were “fighting for our marriage and our life together.” She answered, “You have mine.” Then she quit the show in silence.
YOU MAY LIKEMykelti’s Truth Bomb: Are You Watching Sister Wives for the Moms — or to Yell at Kody?Candidate No. 3: TLC — the Cameras That Won’t Look Away
The third suspect is not a person at all. On November 18, Reddit turned on the network itself after Meri’s tantra speed-dating night aired, with one viewer calling the filmed exercise “horrifyingly misogynistic” and another asking, “Who the hell is making her do this stuff? The producers?” The same cameras filmed the therapy sessions and the ring-burning on November 8. To one camp, the show is finally giving the women their voice back. To the other, it is the same old machine: the family is gone, but the pain is still good television.
Candidate No. 4: Kody Brown — the Ghost Still Writing the Story

Kody has not filmed a single scene of Season 21, and he is still in every argument. In the season premiere, Janelle answered his claim that she had schemed a “backdoor deal” to cut Meri out of the Coyote Pass sale: “I feel like the apology tour was, in the end, something he was trying to redeem himself with, and I don’t think it was necessarily that sincere because there’s been no contact since.” Her verdict: “So, f—k him.” She called the accusation “a final F-U as he was leaving” — and she learned about the exit by email, not from her ex-husband.
Then this week, Kody broke his own silence — briefly. In a since-deleted Instagram statement, he wrote that he and Robyn were “no longer interested in the narrative that is being shared” and had decided “our peace cannot be bought.” He left without apologizing to his children — Janelle estimates he is “alienated from 90 to 95 percent” of them.
So here is the ballot: David’s ultimatum, Robyn’s silence, TLC’s cameras, or Kody’s parting shot at Janelle — which one did the most damage this season, and if you could make one of them apologize first, who would it be?
More Sister Wives drama
Sister WivesChristine Brown’s $770K Lehi Home, a 4.98-Star Rental Empire and the Utah Life She Built After Kody
Sister WivesJanelle Brown Left Kody With Nothing — Her Starting-Over Timeline Tells a Different Story
Sister WivesKody Told the Ex-Wives to Stop Using Him for Storyline — Two Months Later, Who Actually Needs Whom?



