“This story is just beginning.” That is what Matt McAdams wrote under an Instagram photo of himself, his mother Kelly and his girlfriend Devon. It is the loudest thing anyone from the show has said in public since the Season 4 finale, 731 days ago. It is also not a renewal announcement. It is a job application.
According to reports, TLC has announced no fifth season and said nothing at all. The Futon Critic files the series under “on hiatus or fate to be determined.” All 43 episodes still stream on HBO Max, Hulu, Discovery+ and TLC GO. The real question is not whether TLC remembers the show, but who would even be left to film it.
The Only Audition in Town: Matt, Kelly and Devon
If anyone is campaigning for a comeback, it is Matt McAdams. He recently sat down for The Sarah Fraser Show podcast alongside his mother Kelly and his girlfriend Devon, all three together. His caption read: “Devon and I are so excited for the future and mom’s ready for the ride!”
An audition, not a confirmation — but the turnaround is real. Kelly once said out loud that she did not want to share her son. Matt spent four years with Kim inside Kelly’s world, then ended things with Brittany Taylor in a cheating scandal he later owned as taking “a coward’s way out.” The podcast truce that followed turned the show’s most feared mother into its most unlikely cheerleader. If Season 5 ever films, this trio has already done the screen test.
The Wedding That Never Got an Answer: Chase, Lori and Natasha

Chase Tyson, his mother Lori Boatright and his fiancée Natasha arrived together in Season 4. Two years on: no wedding, no chosen side, no public update. Lori’s line — her son should “sleep in the middle” — still hangs in the air, and Natasha’s answer, that she has to come first, never got its reply. Their unfinished triangle stopped mid-sentence on November 18, 2024.
The Florida Standoff: Josh, Janelle and Tina
Josh, Janelle and Tina are the show’s longest-running triangle. Twelve years in, Janelle snapped at the finale: “Doesn’t matter what I want, it’s what Tina wants.” Her answer: a Florida house with no room for Tina. Tina’s: a mother-in-law suite — “What is yours is mine,” she told her daughter-in-law, “You are not his wife!” and “I came first.” According to reports, the marriage is intact, and Josh has never lived apart from his mother. The Season 4 finale left the standoff there: two women, one house, no winner.
YOU MAY LIKEThe Women Who Walked Away: 4 Exes Who Escaped I Love a Mama’s BoyThe $25 Ring and the Third Wheel: Shahid, Dia and Nylah

In fall 2024, Shahid Hinton walked into a jewelry store with a budget of “like $25” — the allowance his mother Dia had handed him that morning. Two years in with Nylah, the show called them “verbally engaged.” Dia judged Nylah on sight and never revised it, told Shahid she would eventually be gone, and warned Nylah she was a third wheel. At the finale, she walked into Nylah’s birthday party hot, clapping while Nylah leaned over the cake. No public update since has settled where Shahid and Nylah stand.
The Rest of the Roll Call — and the Verdict
Shekeb, Emily and Laila round out Season 4, and they have gone quiet too. Jason and Justina are still engaged — six years after arriving in Season 1 with a daughter, Taylor, and a wedding to plan, the only Season 1 pair who never came back for Season 2. Justina’s Instagram bio still reads “Fiancé to @jasonmcclay,” and no wedding photos have ever surfaced publicly. Roberto and Kristy are still together according to reports, after the 99.99 percent result Nancy still rejected.
So here is everything we know: TLC has said nothing, and only one trio has campaigned on camera. When Warner Bros. Discovery renewed it for Season 3, its press release bragged Season 2 drew 1.4 million viewers. Formats with that track record do not usually get buried quietly. Until TLC says “cancelled,” the door stays open — and the cast is standing in it.
Now the casting call is yours: if TLC green-lights Season 5 tomorrow, which three triangles make the cut — and who gets cut? Matt’s trio already auditioned. Chase still owes Natasha an answer. Janelle still owes Tina a wall. Pick your three — and tell us who you would cut first.







