Seven years dating Ashley — and Jonah Johnston still sleeps under Trent and Amber’s roof. Emma Johnston just turned 21, and only now did she say the word “Yes” when asked if she even wants a boyfriend. Meanwhile Liz, 24, is married with two kids.
Same parents, same house, same rules — three wildly different finish lines. After a decade of watching Trent and Amber raise five kids on camera, the fandom has split in two: too strict, or just right? Pick a side.
Did the Rules Raise Adults — or Just Delay Adulthood?
Start with Jonah. Seven years with Ashley, no ring, no place of his own — and, per The Ashley’s Reality Roundup in late October, tensions rising between father and son over exactly that. Team Too Strict sees the bill coming due: a young man who followed the rules so well he never learned to break away.
Team Just Right sees a son with no debt, no rushed wedding, still arguing with his parents at the dinner table. To that camp, the house rules Trent and Amber set for their five kids were a launchpad with a long runway — and Jonah is simply still on it.
Is Liz Proof the System Worked?

If Jonah is the prosecution’s star witness, Liz is the defense’s. She married Brice Bolden in November 2025, welcomed Leighton in 2023, and gave birth to son Coleman on September 8, 2026 — a second pregnancy the new season follows on screen, C-section fears and all.
Team Just Right calls Liz Exhibit A: everything in order, young and steady. Team Too Strict fires back: she built her life on the Johnston template — married young, babies early, family first. Independence, or the same script with a new cast?
YOU MAY LIKEEverything We Know About 7 Little Johnstons Season 18 — Wedding Bells, New Homes, and One Big Question MarkOr Does Anna’s Empty Chair Answer the Question?
Then there is the empty chair. Anna left after Season 16 and does not appear in Season 18, according to reports — and in October she was arrested in Georgia on suspicion of DUI, according to reports, then released the next day on a $1,563 bond. Trent told PEOPLE last December the door stays open: “When Anna alone wants to sit down with her mom and dad and start building this fence together, we’ll do it.”
Team Too Strict points at that empty chair: the child who pushed back hardest is the one no longer at the table. Team Just Right answers that every family has a fracture — but that is where the standoff over who calls first keeps the argument alive.
What About the Ones Still Deciding?

Emma is the season’s live experiment. At 21 she finally said she wants a boyfriend — one word, “Yes,” that the whole trailer hangs on — and per The Ashley’s Reality Roundup, Ashley and Allie are already playing matchmaker for her. Alex has quietly built his own lane behind the camera.
So here is the question splitting the fandom: if a 21-year-old needs a family committee to land a first boyfriend, is that protection — or proof the rules ran too long? Emma saying yes to dating at 21 should have been the season’s simplest storyline. Instead it became the referendum on everything Trent and Amber taught her.
So — Too Strict, or Just Right?
Liz: the system worked. Jonah: still waiting. Emma: just starting. Alex: building quietly. Anna: the empty chair that will not let the debate end.
Trent and Amber built the fence. Liz climbed over it and built her own house. Jonah is still deciding whether to open the gate. So tell us straight: would you let Emma go on a first date without a family meeting — or hand her the full Johnston rulebook first?
More 7 Little Johnstons drama
7 Little JohnstonsAmber Johnston at 47: The Timeline From a 1995 Convention to Season 18’s Menopause Party
7 Little JohnstonsSeven Years, No Ring, Still at Home: Should Trent and Amber Push Jonah and Ashley to the Next Step?
7 Little JohnstonsAmber Johnston Baked a Cake for Her Uterus — and Fans Can’t Decide If It’s Brave or Too Much



