On September 1, Tammy Slaton climbed onto a horse for the first time in her life. Before the ride was over, her fiancée Andrea Dalton had proposed on horseback — and Tammy said yes on the spot.
Six years after the show premiered with two sisters weighing a combined 1,000-plus pounds, all five Slaton siblings have had bariatric surgery. But they have not changed equally — and one week after the finale, the race looks nothing like it did in 2020.
We have ranked this family before — our earlier ranking of total change since Season 1 measured the whole six-year road. This one measures who is winning RIGHT NOW. Fifth to first.
No. 5 — Amanda Halterman: The Biggest Loss, the Coldest Week

The cruelest number in this family: Amanda has lost more than 300 pounds since her gastric bypass, according to reports. She had surgery on the same day as Misty in March 2023. So why last? Because this ranking is about right now — the coldest week of Amanda’s year. In Episode 8, Tammy took back Amanda, Misty and Chris’s Nashville invitations. Her body did the work — her family did not meet her halfway.
No. 4 — Misty Slaton: 74 Pounds and Zero Applause
Misty is the eldest sibling, the quietest presence on the show — and, by the numbers, one of its biggest success stories. She waited years for surgery out of fear, then had it the same day as Amanda in March 2023, according to reports — 240 pounds to 166, diabetes medication gone. Fans have called her the most underrated Slaton. But quiet is the problem: Season 9 gave her almost nothing, just the same Nashville uninvite. A medical triumph — with the momentum of a whisper.
No. 3 — Chris Combs: The Steady Hand Got Shaken

Chris Combs has been the sibling everyone calls when things fall apart. He started at over 450 pounds, had bariatric surgery in 2022, lost around 150, then dropped another 60 and earned skin-removal surgery in Season 6. His reason: his dad died at 57, between 400 and 500 pounds. “I want to be around my family,” Chris said. Season 9 tested him: he confronted Amy over her silence, and Amanda and Misty handed him a taste of his own medicine. The comeback is real.
YOU MAY LIKEAmy Slaton’s 1st Anniversary Photos Just Answered the Question Everyone Asked About BrianNo. 2 — Amy Slaton: A New Marriage, a Song — and a Checklist
Amy started at 406 pounds with one goal: she wanted to be a mom. She lost 124 pounds to qualify for surgery, then had the bypass — and three years later had lost 176 pounds, according to reports. Two sons followed. Then a Halloween wedding to Brian Lovvorn in 2025, and a debut single, “Pounds Hollow.” So why not first? Her next chapter is still on a checklist: Dr. Katie approved skin-removal surgery if she loses 20 more pounds and quits smoking. Amy planned to quit Monday. Amanda told her to start now.
No. 1 — Tammy Slaton: From 725 Pounds to the Aisle in 24 Days
Nobody else in this family was ever supposed to make it here. Tammy weighed 725 pounds at her heaviest, used a wheelchair and oxygen. After rehab and bariatric surgery in July 2022, she has lost more than 500 pounds — down to a reported 238 by Season 7, with January 2025 skin-removal surgery taking off 15 more, according to reports. She rode a horse in the Season 9 premiere. In 24 days, she walks down the aisle. It is not a clean win: Andrea’s health scare is still a “maybe tumor,” and three of Tammy’s siblings were uninvited from Nashville. But on distance and momentum, she is alone at the top.
Here is the argument for the comments: Amanda lost more than 300 pounds and still finished last, because the family froze her out of Nashville. Should a power ranking punish a sibling for where she stands with Tammy — or should 300 pounds carry Amanda past Chris into third? Tell us where you would put Amanda, and who you would bump.







