TRENDING Felix Wrote ‘Love U Mimi’ in Petals — Then Michelle Turned On the Shower“I Can’t Feel Sorry for Andrea Anymore” — Fans Split as Slur Allegation Hits 24 Days Before Tammy’s WeddingMeri and Janelle Showed Up for Leon Brown After Koda’s Death
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › 1000-Lb Sisters
1000-Lb Sisters

“I Can’t Feel Sorry for Andrea Anymore” — Fans Split as Slur Allegation Hits 24 Days Before Tammy’s Wedding

“I Can’t Feel Sorry for Andrea Anymore” — Fans Split as Slur Allegation Hits 24 Days Before Tammy’s Wedding

On November 16, a Reddit post titled “Andrea saying N word” claimed Andrea Dalton used the N-word during a social-media livestream. By the next morning, a second thread carried a different title: “I can’t feel sorry for Andrea anymore.” That is the sharpest turn of the season: the viewers who spent the fall defending Tammy Slaton’s fiancée, now split over an allegation nobody has verified.

The timing could hardly be worse. Andrea met Tammy on a dating app, joined the show in April 2025, and proposed in the September 1 Season 9 premiere. Tammy called her fiancée on a podcast that July; the engagement went public July 22. The season wrapped with the finale on November 10, and the wedding is set for December 12 — 24 days away — while the couple is in therapy over trust issues. Until this week, fans had mostly rallied around Andrea.

A Reddit Post, a Facebook Story and a Song

According to reports, the claim began with a Reddit post on November 16 alleging Andrea used the N-word during a livestream, with the poster saying the clip was on Andrea’s Facebook Story. No clip has been independently verified; the allegation rests on what fans say they heard, not on any statement from Andrea, Tammy or TLC. A secondhand Reddit comment says Andrea explained it as “We were just singing a song” — not a direct quote from Andrea herself.

Tammy in the Background: Giggling, Silent or Just There?

Some commenters believe a background voice sounds like Tammy Slaton — and even there, fans disagree on what they heard. On November 17, one person said Tammy was “kinda giggling and saying ‘yeah,'” while another said she “isn’t laughing” but was still part of the moment. Each reading is only a fan’s interpretation of the same alleged clip, and neither has been confirmed. It decides which Tammy fans walk away with — a fiancée laughing along, or a bystander caught in someone else’s livestream.

Amy Slaton and Tammy Slaton sitting together on a couch, both looking serious
Amy Slaton and Tammy Slaton. The sisters have stood by each other all season — now fans are split over the woman Tammy is set to marry. (Still: TLC)

From Sympathy to “I Can’t Feel Sorry for Andrea Anymore”

The speed of the turn is what stands out. Fans spent months defending Andrea — as Tammy’s new love, then through the season’s scary diagnosis storyline. Now, according to reports, some of those same viewers want Andrea “cancelled” and ask what TLC will do with a cast member facing this allegation. The November 17 thread reads like a line drawn. It is not the week’s first blow: a wave of claims about her past surfaced days earlier, and the slur allegation landed on top.

The other camp reads the whole thing differently. To them, the timing — one controversy days after another, weeks before a wedding — is the story, and an unverified clip is not enough to undo a person. They note no outlet has confirmed the audio, the “singing a song” explanation stands undisproved, and the loudest voices are the same ones who turned on Andrea days earlier. Two fandoms, arguing over the same 48 hours.

Amy Slaton’s 1st Anniversary Photos Just Answered the Question Everyone Asked About BrianYOU MAY LIKEAmy Slaton’s 1st Anniversary Photos Just Answered the Question Everyone Asked About Brian
Tammy Slaton and her brother Chris Combs sitting together on a couch
Tammy Slaton and her brother Chris Combs. Chris has worried before about Tammy reliving old heartbreak — the latest allegation puts that fear back in the spotlight. (Still: TLC)

December 12 Is Still on the Calendar

None of this has moved the wedding date. December 12 still stands — her “Snow in Love” wedding vision included, the gazebo proposal from the September 1 premiere, the therapy sessions they are doing now. But a wedding is a public vote of confidence, and the question has changed: a week ago fans asked whether it would be drama-free; now they ask whether the fiancée should be standing beside her at all. Andrea has not addressed the allegation publicly, and TLC has not commented.

So here is the split, 24 days from “I do”: if the clip is never verified and Andrea never answers it, do you stand by the fiancée Tammy chose — or has this week changed how you will watch her walk down the aisle on December 12?

Keep reading

More 1000-Lb Sisters drama

1000-Lb Sisters

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

FEATURING Tammy Slaton
&
KB
Katie Brennan

Katie covers Sister Wives, 1000-Lb Sisters and 7 Little Johnstons for Remote & Tea — cast updates, family news and where-are-they-now stories.

More from 1000-Lb Sisters

See more ›