“Well, yeah. If they text me, I’m going to text them back.” With that one sentence, Andi Jane Wallace turned her open relationship with Nigel into a trap with two different rulebooks. On Sunday night, in Season 8, Episode 7 of 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way, Andi finally confronted Nigel face to face — and the fandom has spent two days arguing one question: who crossed the line first?
Sunday Night: The Confrontation Six Episodes in the Making
The episode, “Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Family,” aired Sunday, November 15, at 8 p.m. ET — the episode TLC billed as her showdown with Nigel over Azrael. According to Memorable TV, it lived up to the billing: a woman Nigel had hooked up with moved out of his place days before Andi landed, and Azrael, the fire-spinning “part-time lover,” is one he has no intention of giving up. The road here was short. The season premiered October 4 with Andi already doubting the move, and on October 24 she admitted to her family that distance alone had made her agree to an open setup — quietly hoping Nigel would drop the other women once she arrived. She never told him. By Episode 5 she had met Azrael at a sound bath, survived cockroach races, and started calling his connections “mini relationships.”
Team Andi: She Crossed an Ocean — He Moved the Goalposts

Andi’s case starts with what she gave up: a Nashville music career on the rise — gigs with her bluegrass band, a fresh album — paused to move to Brisbane for one man. She asked him for monogamy, for the time being in the November 8 episode — and got a conditional yes: Nigel agreed temporarily, said lifelong monogamy is not for him, and asked whether she wanted it out of jealousy, and whether they could reopen things once she settled in.
Then the money and the silence. Nigel got Andi to put a $10,000 timeshare on her credit card, then stopped helping her pay it — and went days without replying to her texts. She says she looked for connection elsewhere because she did not always feel it from him; he blames festivals with no reception. To Team Andi, the math is simple: she crossed the planet for a partner and got a part-time lover with a festival schedule.
Team Nigel: She Signed Up for Open — Then Rewrote the Rules
Nigel’s case starts with the deal: a self-described “poly person” who found polyamory after his divorce, and a couple who agreed to ethical non-monogamy while living apart. Then Andi downloaded a dating app, texted and flirted with two men under his roof, and slept with one. When Nigel asked if the messages were still going, she did not deny it. He called it “crossing a line” and emotional cheating: he has no “ongoing text message relationships” with his lovers, and his connections stay physical. To Team Nigel, the rule was never “no one else” — it was “no secret emotional affairs.” Even TLC saw it coming: announcing Season 8, it flagged that the two view non-monogamy very differently, and warned rows over children and fertility could break them.
The Festival Posts That Keep Fueling the Fire

Off screen, the evidence fans keep screenshotting is dated November 3. Nigel shared Instagram Stories from the Earth Frequency Festival — a 210-DJ gathering at Woodfordia, north of Brisbane — dancing face-to-face with Azrael during the “Bangers & Crash” finale. Andi appeared nowhere. Fans read the clips as a breakup hint, and some speculate she has already returned to the United States — though neither has confirmed a breakup.
YOU MAY LIKESTOP Sharing That Viral Post: The Cruel Jenny Slatten Death Hoax Debunked — She’s Alive and Still FightingSunday Changed the Question — Now It’s About Survival
That is why Sunday mattered more than the fight. TV Season & Spoilers put it plainly on November 10: fans doubt whether Andi and Nigel can survive their trust problem at all. The confrontation did not settle the rules — it proved they never agreed on them. She thought “open” was a long-distance fix with an expiry date. He thought it was the relationship. Next episode: Sunday, November 22, 8 p.m. ET.
So pick a side — on the facts. If Nigel’s “for the time being” was never a real yes, and Andi’s texts were never a real betrayal, then who actually broke the rules first: the woman who answered two men back, or the man who danced with Azrael while she was still unpacking her life in Brisbane?







