Ten thousand dollars a year. That is the bill Andi is still paying on the Mexico timeshare she bought with Nigel — and when she raised it during her tattoo appointment, his answer was to cancel the credit card she pays it with.
The exchange aired in Season 8, Episode 7 of 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way, “Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Family,” on Sunday, November 15. The argument escaped the episode: our Episode 7 ranking put the couple near the bottom, and on Reddit the fandom split into camps still arguing.
The Side That Says Nigel Left Her Holding the Bill
Team Andi starts with one fact: she is the one making the payments. Andi, a Nashville musician, paused her career to move to Australia for him; Nigel, a First Nations DJ and drummer in Brisbane, calls himself a “poly person,” and the pair started out open. None of that changes whose name is on the card.
“Just because you cancel the credit card does not cancel the debt,” one commenter wrote — now Team Andi’s rallying cry. Their point: cancelling a card does not cancel a $10,000-a-year contract; the debt would follow Andi. To them, a partner is leaving the other one to carry a bill he helped create.

The Side That Says Andi Walked In With Her Eyes Open
Team Nigel fires back with a colder case: Andi knew the plan. Others say she bought it knowing Nigel meant to cancel the card, and cannot act blindsided. She moved for a man open about being non-monogamous, they say, and signed up for the timeshare with him — and buyers do not get to rewrite the deal once the payments get heavy.
The Frequent-Flyer Miles Nobody Saw Coming
Both camps keep missing the detail that drove Andi’s objection. She did not think the balance would vanish. She had built up frequent-flyer miles on that card — miles she would lose if it were cancelled. Her refusal was not about maths. It was about the card being hers.
YOU MAY LIKESTOP Sharing That Viral Post: The Cruel Jenny Slatten Death Hoax Debunked — She’s Alive and Still FightingThat detail reframes the fight. Andi was not asking Nigel to solve a debt. She was telling him his solution cost her something real, and he had not noticed. Nigel’s promise to pay his share came only after that exchange, when he acknowledged he had let Andi down; a November 17 recap confirmed he agreed to cover his portion.

Why a Money Fight Reads Like a Trust Fight
Neither side is really arguing about a timeshare — which is why the thread will not die. By the time of her tattoo appointment, the trust gap was already months old. Andi had met his lovers face to face, including fire-spinner Azrael, his “most recent, sort of, part-time lover.” She called his connections “mini relationships” and admitted she felt like “one of many.”
Then came the texts. Nigel confronted Andi over texts to a former lover — she had “crossed a line,” he said — while calling his own connections purely physical. Andi countered that he went quiet whenever he was with other women. They agreed to monogamy “at least for now.” But according to reports, his Instagram Stories with Azrael had fans thinking they had already split. Small wonder the credit-card fight reads as a fight about whether Nigel chooses her.
The Third Camp That Blames Them Both
Then the bluntest camp: fans who dislike both of them. To them, the timeshare is a mess the couple built together — one rushed purchase, one careless escape plan, and two people mistaking a promise for a payment.
New episodes air Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on TLC, with Episode 8 expected on Sunday, November 22. If Nigel starts paying his share, does that settle it — or has the “cancel the card” moment already told Andi who carries the cost in this relationship?







