TRENDING Sister Wives: Where Are They Now? Christine’s Therapy, Janelle’s Pete, Meri’s Feyd — and Kody’s SilenceMatilda Said No, Hannah Turns 14, and Felix Has Explaining to Do: Sunday on The Other WayHis Card Got Declined at Dinner — Because His Mom Moved His Money
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › The Family Chantel
The Family Chantel

Karen’s P.I. Said Pedro Cheated. Three Years Later, Was She Right?

Karen’s P.I. Said Pedro Cheated. Three Years Later, Was She Right?

Chantel Everett in tears, facing Pedro Jimeno — the confrontation at the heart of the cheating question Karen's private investigator raised. (Showbiz Cheat Sheet / TLC)

“If I was a betting man, I would say that I’m pretty sure that between the two ladies, he was not doing right by your daughter.”

That is what the private investigator hired by Karen Everett said on camera in the November 2023 episode of The Family Chantel titled “A Rose by Any Other Name.” The clip is circulating again this week — and the oldest fight in this fandom is back with it. Karen told her daughter, flatly: “He was fooling on you.” Chantel’s answer still lands like a gut punch: “That’s really messed up because I had been on, you know, dinners with her, I’ve been to that lady’s house. I confided in that lady.”

Both exes have moved on since. The question now is simpler, and harder: was Karen right?

Team Karen: “He Was Fooling on You”

Team Karen starts with the investigator’s report. According to the P.I., Pedro went on what the office called a “business trip” with two coworkers, and “all signs point to that he was probably with the older female.” That woman, according to Karen, was Pedro’s mentor at work — the colleague Chantel had trusted enough to confide in about her own marriage.

Then there is the pattern. In a November 2023 episode, Karen said: “He used our daughter for seven long years.” The P.I. also claimed Pedro had a prior relationship with Coraima, a friend of his sister Nicole, despite Pedro insisting they were nothing. Chantel’s response: “My blood is boiling… now I feel like he was cheating on me the entire time.”

Pedro Jimeno looking serious in a confessional interview on The Family Chantel, wearing a maroon shirt
Pedro Jimeno — he has always denied cheating, and the investigator himself called his findings ‘just an assumption.’ (MEAWW / TLC)

Team Pedro: “It Was Just an Assumption”

Team Pedro starts with the investigator’s own words — the part Karen’s side skips. The P.I. admitted what he had gathered was “just an assumption.” No photos, no messages, no hard proof ever aired. What viewers got was a betting man’s hunch from a man Karen herself had hired.

Karen and Thomas Everett: The Marriage That Survived Every Chantel Storm — and the One Wedding Question LeftYOU MAY LIKEKaren and Thomas Everett: The Marriage That Survived Every Chantel Storm — and the One Wedding Question Left

Pedro has always denied cheating with his coworker Antonella Barrenechea, and according to reports, Antonella had a boyfriend of her own. Nothing linking them romantically was ever proven. Team Pedro’s argument is blunt: a mother who already believed her son-in-law was a gold digger paid an investigator, and the investigator told her what she paid to hear.

The Mentor in the Middle: The Woman Chantel Trusted

This is the detail that keeps the debate alive, because it is the one that hurts most. Antonella Barrenechea was not a stranger. She was Pedro’s colleague at Laura Delgado Realty. Chantel once asked him on camera when it became normal for her husband to come home at 3 a.m. without explanation — and said he drove Antonella home.

That is why Chantel’s confessional still stings: “Pedro’s coworker was somebody who I once felt like I could trust, and I confided in them. But that was all a ruse.” Team Karen’s favorite line follows: “They were most likely an item, and they were both gaslighting me together.” If the affair was never proven, the betrayal of trust was still real to Chantel.

Chantel Everett and Pedro Jimeno sitting apart on a couch, tense and not touching, during a confessional segment
Chantel Everett and Pedro Jimeno, sitting apart — the distance between them was already visible long before the divorce. (Reality TV World / TLC)

Three Years Later: Two Weddings, One Unanswered Question

Here is where 2026 changes the argument. Chantel married Ashley Bowen on October 17, 2026, in the wedding that started her new chapter — sixty guests and a helicopter exit. Pedro is engaged to Valentina Malagon, and the couple recently took his quietest step with Valentina, a shared baptism. No wedding date has been confirmed, and his mother Lidia still has not given her blessing.

So the old question has a new edge. If Karen’s investigator was right, Pedro walked into his next engagement carrying the same secret. If he was wrong, Karen spent years smearing a man who had simply fallen out of love — the same fault line as the debate over which family actually broke the marriage, only this time the evidence is one man’s “assumption.”

Three years later, with both of them married or engaged to someone else, the verdict still belongs to the fans. Team Karen or Team Pedro — and what would it actually take to change your mind?

Keep reading

More The Family Chantel drama

The Family Chantel

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

FEATURING Karen Derrico
&
MC
Megan Carter

Megan covers 90 Day Fiancé and its spin-offs for Remote & Tea — episode recaps, spoilers and the fan debates that follow every episode.

More from The Family Chantel

See more ›