“If they were struggling academically, why take them out for an untrained individual to teach them?” That comment follows Danielle Busby everywhere she posts about homeschooling — and on October 5, she answered it, with a first-month update honest about both the calm and the cost.
“Every day looks a little different, but I feel like the quints and I have adjusted to what our new ‘school days’, and really, our days in general, look like,” Danielle wrote on Instagram. She likes the slower pace — and misses having time for herself. It was the first report card on the Busbys’ biggest parenting call in years — five 11-year-olds, Ava, Olivia, Hazel, Riley and Parker, starting sixth grade at home, landing in the middle of the homeschool-versus-public-school debate that has split OutDaughtered fans since February.
Team Homeschool: “Because of, and for, the Quints”
Danielle’s case starts with the girls themselves. She chose homeschooling “because of, and for, the quints” — most of them struggled academically in different areas, with different learning styles, dyslexia and gaps a crowded classroom kept missing. Add public middle school’s pressures, and the co-op — home learning at their own pace, some subjects in a classroom — looked like the answer. Supporters say that is the whole point: five different kids, five different needs, one parent who actually knows them.
What has not changed matters too: the quints still play sports, still do extracurriculars, still see old friends through the co-op. And the door stays open: the Busbys would send a daughter back to public school if homeschooling stopped working for her. For Team Homeschool, that open door proves this is a decision, not a dogma.
Team Public School: “Send Your Children to School”
The other side is not buying it. The sharpest version: if the girls were struggling academically, why hand them to “an untrained individual”? Others aimed at the faith language around the decision — “Save the religion for church. Send your children to school.” Reddit has chewed over the same split for weeks, and, according to reports, the wilder theories about politics, money or control remain unconfirmed — which has not stopped anyone repeating them.

The Twist Nobody Expected: Adam Changed His Mind
Then episode 108 of More Than Reality, released November 12, added a wrinkle neither side expected. Adam said his view changed after he took over teaching the quints while Danielle was away — the doubting dad got a turn at the front of the class — and came out different. The episode revisited Danielle’s reasons in full, in episode 108’s 51-minute fan Q&A. What it did not settle: whether each quint actually enjoys homeschooling. That is still unconfirmed — and episode 109, out November 19, stuck to parenting rules instead.
YOU MAY LIKEAdam Busby’s Halloween Scare Totally Backfired — 5 Wild Busby Halloween Moments RankedWhat Month Two Has to Prove
The timeline: decision announced February 26, debated on episode 96 on August 20, first-day photo August 25 (“late morning start”), first week “mentally draining” by September 3, first-month update October 5. Their first homeschool semester, told in order, reads like a family learning in public — brave or the problem, depending on your team.

What month two must prove is narrower than the comment threads pretend: not whether homeschooling is right in general, but whether five 11-year-olds are learning, happy and still themselves by Christmas. The co-op, the sports, the friendships — that is the evidence both teams are watching now.
So here is the question Danielle’s update leaves behind: if one quint thrives at the kitchen table and another quietly misses her old classroom, should Danielle let each girl choose her own school — even if it splits the five for the first time? Team Homeschool or Team Public School: pick your side, and say which quint you think would choose differently.
More OutDaughtered drama
OutDaughteredFair Doesn’t Mean Equal: Adam & Danielle Busby’s Episode 109 Parenting Rules Split Fans in Two
OutDaughteredAre Adam and Danielle Busby Still the Same Couple Fans Fell For?
OutDaughteredDanielle Busby Grew Up With Twin Sisters 13 Months Older — And It Explains Everything About Her Six Daughters



