TRENDING She Waited 20 Years — Then Asked for a Ball Gown That Takes Five Minutes to ArriveThe Comeback Deal: What Shauna Rae Would Have to Give Up for a Season 3Janelle’s First Date Airs Tonight — Here’s Every Sister Wives Moment Still to Come
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › Unexpected
Unexpected

Every Unexpected Couple Ranked by Staying Power: Marriages, Comebacks and the Messiest Split

Every Unexpected Couple Ranked by Staying Power: Marriages, Comebacks and the Messiest Split

Emersyn Potter and Mason Ramirez with newborn son Mateo during Unexpected Season 5. (TLC via TV Shows Ace)

Three years. That is how long Lilly Bennett and Lawrence Bishop have been married — longer than some Unexpected couples lasted from first date to final breakup. Here they are, ranked by staying power: the marriages that refuse to break, the quiet survivors, the comebacks — and the split that broke the fandom.

No. 1–2: The Marriages That Refuse to Break

Lilly Bennett and Lawrence Bishop at their baby shower
Lilly Bennett and Lawrence Bishop at their baby shower — the couple fans call the gold standard. (Soap Dirt)

Lilly and Lawrence set the standard for every other Unexpected couple. Together since 2019 and married in March 2023, they marked their third anniversary this March: “3 years married to my best friend.” They share son LJ. Right behind them: Emalee Lenhard and Nate Alden, married in May 2024 after a two-month courtship and a baby. They celebrated their second anniversary this year, and in July Emalee announced a baby girl is due in February, with Westley holding an “I Am a Big Brother” book.

No. 3–6: The Quiet Survivors Nobody Bets On

Kylen Smith and Jason Korpi during Unexpected Season 5
Kylen Smith and Jason Korpi during Unexpected Season 5. (TLC via TV Season & Spoilers)

Kylen Smith and Jason Korpi keep proving the doubters wrong. Four years after Season 5, they are still together, now parents of two: Xavier and Oakley, born in October 2024. Jason put it bluntly on TikTok: “This family saved me.” Emersyn Potter and Mason Ramirez never gave the fandom much to argue about: they welcomed son Mateo in June 2021 and simply stayed together, away from the spotlight. Myrka Cantu and Juan Castillo are the list’s biggest family: four kids before Myrka turned 23. Jenna Ronan and JJ Della round out the tier: engaged in October 2023, parents a month later, still together.

No. 7–8: The Comebacks — Split, Then Stronger

Mia and Jessie had the wildest year of any Unexpected couple: their house burned down on January 25, 2026, and four months later Jessie was down on one knee in New Orleans — after asking Mia’s dad for permission first — while Mia held baby Oakleigh. Engaged, with no wedding date yet — the only Season 7 couple that never split. Isabella and Bryce’s full timeline runs from a February ring to an October heartbreak: broken up when Haisley was born in May 2025, reconciled, engaged on February 7, 2026 — then a second pregnancy in August, lost on October 9 when no heartbeat could be found. Still engaged, according to reports.

No. 9–11: The Splits That Rewrote the Show

Amaya and Jose split when son Sammy was just months old — then the Season 7 finale surprised everyone: Amaya revealed she was dating her girlfriend Jahnay, 18. Chloe Mendoza and Max Schenzel split in early 2020; in September 2026, Max announced his father Todd had died of brain cancer. Rilah Ferrer’s story took the darkest turn: ex Anthony was sentenced to four years in prison in a 2023 aggravated-battery case, Rilah pleaded no contest to a cyber-harassment charge in August 2026 — and welcomed a baby girl around September with new boyfriend Eddie. McKayla Adkins has been married twice since her split with Caelan Morrison.

No. 12: Last Place, and It Isn’t Close

Bella Vaughn and Hunter Johnson did everything faster than anyone: the youngest couple in show history, engaged on May 6, 2026, split 23 days later. They reconciled on June 22, posting “We back bby” from Topgolf, then split again in mid-July. On November 3, Bella hard-launched Ashton, a boyfriend she boasted is “old enough to drive”; Hunter moved on with Ambria, 16. A custody war over Wes rages on in Arkansas court. Every other couple here either made it work or walked away clean — Bella and Hunter did neither.

Unexpected Couples Ranked: Who Is Still Together in October 2026?YOU MAY LIKEUnexpected Couples Ranked: Who Is Still Together in October 2026?

So here is the argument: is Lilly and Lawrence’s three-year marriage proof teen love can last, or are Emalee and Nate the only couple that figured out the formula? And did Bella and Hunter ever stand a chance — or was a 23-day engagement always going to end at the bottom?

Keep reading

More Unexpected drama

Unexpected

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
LH
Lauren Hayes

Lauren covers My Big Fat Fabulous Life, I Am Shauna Rae, OutDaughtered, Doubling Down with the Derricos, I Love a Mama's Boy, Unexpected and Welcome to Plathville for Remote & Tea — cast updates, recaps and fan debates.

More from Unexpected

See more ›