TRENDING 5 People Who Hold Whitney and Jake’s Engagement in Their Hands, RankedThe Quints Are 13 and the Cameras Are Rolling Again — Should They Film the Comeback?‘Disgusting’ and ‘Never Be Friends’: Everything We Know About the Yara–Jasmine War Before 90 Day: Florida
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › Say Yes to the Dress
Say Yes to the Dress

She Wanted a ‘Classy Porn Star’ Dress — Then Said Yes to Simple

She Wanted a ‘Classy Porn Star’ Dress — Then Said Yes to Simple

The yes moment — Lauren in the veil, hugging her mom Toni, with Randy Fenoli behind them. (TLC)

Lauren Burdey walked into Kleinfeld with a vision she could sum up in three words — and the salon knew it would start a fight. The Jersey girl came with a $5,000 budget, her mom Toni, her twin sister Caitlin, her future mother-in-law Marina, and her best friend Kelly. Her fiancé Anthony stayed home. When Allison asked what the ultimate dress meant, Lauren did not hesitate: “classy porn star.” Low cleavage, loud sparkle, a big poofy ball gown. (Season 13, “Vision Confusion.”)

Lauren Burdey in the sparkling Eve of Milady ball gown at Kleinfeld, with Randy Fenoli and consultant Allison beside her
The dream dress — an Eve of Milady ball gown, $3,500, with Randy Fenoli and consultant Allison. (TLC)

The Ball Gown That Wasn’t Classy

First up: the dress Lauren had pictured — an Eve of Milady ball gown, $3,500, all sparkle and full skirt. On the pedestal, it fell apart. Her entourage said it looked just like her prom dress. Then: “You look like a cake topper.” Lauren’s verdict was harsher — it was not classy at all, she said, it was “tacky Barbie who probably drinks too much.” Randy spotted the contradiction: her photos were all princess dresses — and nobody had ever seen a porn star in one. His translation: the phrase gets a bad rap — she just wanted a little cleavage, and to feel good.

Lauren Burdey smiling in the simple fitted Perla gown with no beading, the dress Randy Fenoli picked for her
Randy’s gamble — the simple fitted gown, no beading, that made Lauren feel like a bride. (TLC)

Randy’s Gamble: The Simplest Dress in the Salon

What if they went closer? Randy’s choice: a simple fitted Perla gown without a stitch of beading — the opposite of everything she had asked for. Just the word fitted made her want to run: she had always hidden her hips. Then she stepped onto the pedestal, and the room went quiet. She felt like “a pin-up girl and sexy versus trashy,” and her entourage piled on: she looked like she had not had a carb in months — not a prom queen, a bride. She felt like a woman in it — beautiful and confident. It carries the same spirit as Blanche at Gownopia, an ivory silk-satin minimalist gown with no lace, no sparkle, no apology.

The Bow That Split the Twins

Allison tried to split the difference: the same shape, but with a little Jersey girl pizzazz — bling, jewels, a big bow at the hip. Lauren lit up: this was more her — she liked the bling, she liked the bow. Her twin sister Caitlin did not. It looked costumey, Caitlin said — big bow, jewels, very busy — and why was there a bow on it at all? The room sided with Caitlin: the plain gown added to Lauren, instead of turning her into an accessory to the dress. It was a lot to hear, she admitted. So they put the simple dress back on with a veil, and Randy asked the question. “You don’t have to be so showy and blingy to be sexy,” Lauren said. “A hundred percent I’m saying yes to the dress.” The simple, elegant gown was $4,400 — under budget, and nothing like the vision she had walked in with. Randy has pulled off bigger rescues — two rejected Pnina gowns became one $8,600 custom dress — but this time the rescue was subtraction.

Team Sexy vs. Team Simple

Fans split two ways — and the split is the whole episode. Team Sexy says the bride’s vision is hers alone: if she wants low cleavage, loud sparkle and a ball gown, the salon should find it. Team Simple says Randy read her better than she read herself: the fitted gown made her feel like a woman, not a cake topper, and confidence is the sexiest thing a dress can do. Randy has walked out of an appointment before, when a mom mocked Samantha’s dress — but here he stayed, and bet on less. So tell us: if your dream dress is loud, sparkly and low-cut, do you wear it — or do you let the simplest dress in the salon change your mind?

‘Welcome to Plathville’: Ethan Plath Eager for Fatherhood – Is He Ready to Be a Stepdad with His New GF?YOU MAY LIKE‘Welcome to Plathville’: Ethan Plath Eager for Fatherhood – Is He Ready to Be a Stepdad with His New GF?
Keep reading

More Say Yes to the Dress drama

Say Yes to the Dress

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
JM
Jessica Monroe

Jessica covers Say Yes to the Dress and all things bridal for Remote & Tea — the dresses, the consultants and the Kleinfeld moments.

More from Say Yes to the Dress

See more ›