In May, a daughter-in-law in Georgia was scrolling eBay when she stopped on a listing she knew by heart: a one-of-a-kind custom knife, a wedding gift to her husband, on familiar carpet. Her husband had not listed it. That listing, according to an arrest report obtained by Starcasm, is where the felony theft case against Olivia Hopkins began.
Olivia Hopkins, 27, the daughter of 90 Day Fiancé star Molly Hopkins, was booked in Cherokee County on October 27 for felony theft and posted a $4,875 bond the same day, according to jail records. It was her third arrest of 2026. Until November 19, nobody knew what she was accused of taking.
The Knife That Was Never Supposed to Be for Sale
The daughter-in-law spotted the custom Winkler knife on eBay in May; her husband had not created the listing. The same account, according to the report, also listed mostly women’s underwear and clothing. The knife, a one-of-one piece, was believed to be worth $600 to $800.
The homeowners’ son kept firearms and equipment in a basement room, and his mother offered to organize it, with Olivia helping. After the cleanup, two rifle scopes were missing from a workbench — a Crimson Trace 5 Series and a VX Freedom — and both soon appeared on eBay under the same account. The carpet in Olivia’s room matched the listing photo.
Two Scopes, a Jacket and a Pair of Boots
The warrant affidavit, covering May 6 to October 11, 2026, names five items, according to Starcasm: a $500 North Face Cold Spell cropped down puffer jacket; $250 Ugg Adirondack III boots, size 8; a $399.99 Leupold VX-Freedom riflescope; a $1,229.99 Crimson Trace 5 Series tactical riflescope; and the custom, one-of-one Winkler knife at about $800. Together, roughly $3,180, all allegedly sold on eBay, Depop and Poshmark. Under Georgia law, that total can carry one to five years — a booking, though, is not a conviction.
The Family That Took Her In
Olivia had been living with the family since spring, according to the report. The homeowners are an older couple named Hopkins, whose son and daughter-in-law had belongings stored there while building their own home.
YOU MAY LIKEAndi’s Sparrow Flew 5,000 Miles for Nigel — and the Timeshare Came on Day Two
The report also describes a household running out of patience. A cousin told the officer her belongings had often smelled of marijuana, that she has had substance abuse issues and works overnight at Magic City in Atlanta. The cousin also showed the officer a photo of Olivia with facial markings, as if from a fight after she left for New York.
Everyone at the house wanted Olivia out, the report says, but understood they could not simply kick her out. The officer advised them to start eviction proceedings as soon as possible.
Three Arrests in Ten Months — and a File That Reaches Back to 2020
It was her third arrest of 2026 — January brought a driving arrest, August a failure to appear — and the file reaches back to a 2020 battery charge, a 2023 guilty plea and probation, and nine probation violations including a positive fentanyl test. Before 2026, she had gone nearly two years without legal trouble.
The Girl Fans Met at 17
Fans first met Olivia at 17, in Season 5, clashing on camera with her mother’s fiancé, Luis Mendez. Molly and Luis married in secret, then divorced five months later. In late 2022, Olivia accused Molly’s then-boyfriend, ex-NYPD officer Kelly Brown, of choking her, and Molly and Kelly’s breakup followed soon after.

She has since modeled for Molly’s lingerie brand, LiviRae Lingerie, and promoted an Atlanta club as Jade. Molly’s own record shadows the story — Starcasm counts at least four bookings for her, including two DUIs.
Olivia was in New York when officers told the family that housed her to start eviction proceedings. If she comes home to an eviction notice instead of a welcome, should Molly step in for her daughter once more — or let the process play out?







