TRENDING The Page Six Fashion Critic Who Couldn’t Say Yes to Any DressTammy Slaton’s ‘Snow in Love’ Wedding, Ranked: The Crown, the Snow and the Garter TeaseThe Season Armando Didn’t Choose: ‘Our Most Vulnerable Yet’
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › Say Yes to the Dress
Say Yes to the Dress

The Page Six Fashion Critic Who Couldn’t Say Yes to Any Dress

The Page Six Fashion Critic Who Couldn’t Say Yes to Any Dress

Kristen in the long-sleeve lace A-line she loved — the dress with pockets. (TLC)

Kristen walked into Kleinfeld with her phone already out. She is the senior social media editor at Page Six of the New York Post. The pressure was real: she critiques celebrity outfits for a living. She had shopped twice already, chasing a Pronovias Kamala — long sleeve, off-the-shoulder, fitted lace — to beat. Her budget was $3,000, her consultant was Mindy, and her entourage was her mom Terri, her future mother-in-law Nikki, bridesmaid Chelsea and maid of honor Liz. (Season 18, Episode 10.)

The Dress She Came to Beat

No glitz, no open back — Kristen knew what she wanted. Her back is her least favorite part of her body, and her stomach needs covering too. She lost about 90 pounds in high school — and still doubts her arms, stomach and back.

Kristen trying on her first dress at Kleinfeld, an off-the-shoulder lace gown with cap sleeves
Dress one: off-the-shoulder, corseted boning — and the cap sleeves that killed it. (TLC)

The Cap Sleeve That Killed Dress One

Dress one had the neckline and shape she loved — until she looked at the sleeves. “We’re not having a cap sleeve moment. What am I, 70?” she said, and the room laughed. The last thing she needed was trolls calling her a hypocrite for judging other people’s outfits. She wanted a little sleeve, not bare arms. Dress one was done.

Kristen in the Martina Liana fitted lace wedding dress in front of the mirror at Kleinfeld
The Martina Liana at $3,200 — loved, and left behind. (TLC)

The $3,200 Dress She Loved — and Left

The next contender was a Martina Liana at $3,200 — already $200 over her budget — all boning and appliqué, the silhouette she had pictured in her head. Kristen loved the details on her body. But the bottom was not what she pictured, and loving a dress is not the same as marrying it. “I love it, but it’s not for me,” she said, and sent it back. Two dresses in, she had found fault with every gown — too much sequin, too much glitz — and she needed to look perfect.

The One With Pockets

Then Mindy brought out the curveball: an A-line, over budget, nothing like the fitted silhouette she had imagined — but with long sleeves. Kristen put it on just to test whether sleeves were really the deal-breaker. They were not. She “felt kind of like a princess,” she said, and she really loved it. It had something no other dress offered: pockets. “Oh, I love a pocket,” she laughed — snacks, she joked — and the freedom to eat, drink and dance without sucking in all day. Everyone loved it, except the voice in her head. She loved the top, but not the bottom: more A-line, less sexy than the statement she had always imagined. It carries the same spirit as Aurélia at Gownopia, an ivory A-line in hand-appliquéd Chantilly lace. Mindy put it plainly: head versus heart — and her heart wanted sleeves.

’90 Day Fiancé’: Jasmine Pineda Yells ‘F— You’ to Natalie’s Face During Intense Fight!YOU MAY LIKE’90 Day Fiancé’: Jasmine Pineda Yells ‘F— You’ to Natalie’s Face During Intense Fight!

The Last Two Were Never in the Running

One dress never left the fitting room: she had vowed to come out only if she did not look fat in it. The last gown had an illusion top with detached sleeves in what she called “grandma lace.” “Like I feel like Tonya Harding or something,” she said. That is where the clip ends: no yes, no dress. She walked out still hunting.

Head vs. Heart — and No Dress

Fans split two ways. Team Take the A-Line says the dress that made her feel like a princess wins — sleeves, pockets, eat-and-dance freedom. The silhouette was a picture; the A-line was a feeling. Team Wait for the Dream says trust her eye: not sold on the bottom, over budget — and saying yes to a maybe is how you end up hating your wedding photos. Jenna said yes under a two-month deadline, and Heather found hers with one month to go — but Kristen had a dress she genuinely loved, and the nerve to walk away. So tell us: the dress makes you feel like a princess, but it is not the silhouette you pictured — yes, or keep hunting?

Keep reading

More Say Yes to the Dress drama

Say Yes to the Dress

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
JM
Jessica Monroe

Jessica covers Say Yes to the Dress and all things bridal for Remote & Tea — the dresses, the consultants and the Kleinfeld moments.

More from Say Yes to the Dress

See more ›