TRENDING Jenna Johnson’s Reception Dress Came Down to a Midnight Call to ParisShe Lost Her Mom and Her Sister to a ‘Cult’ — Carrie Brown Finally Tells Her Side25 Hours, $12 an Hour, 25 Percent: Mama G’s Rule for Jose — and the Month It Ended
☕ Fresh reality tea, served daily — never miss a spoiler from this show.
Home › Shows › Say Yes to the Dress
Say Yes to the Dress

Jenna Johnson’s Reception Dress Came Down to a Midnight Call to Paris

Jenna Johnson’s Reception Dress Came Down to a Midnight Call to Paris

Jenna in the Tony Ward reception dress she said yes to — dancing with Randy Fenoli. (TLC)

Jenna Johnson dances for a living — every Monday night, on Dancing with the Stars. At Kleinfeld, Randy Fenoli expected a bride who knew exactly how a dress should move. He did not expect the deadline: two months to the wedding, and the dress that mattered most did not exist yet. Not her ceremony gown — her reception dress, the second dress, the one she would wear longest. She had left it until last.

The Dancer Who Saved the Dress for Last

Jenna told Randy she lives her dream every Monday night on Dancing with the Stars. She is marrying Val at the California resort where the two of them met. With her: mom Tammy, family friend Stacey, future mother-in-law Larissa, and future sister-in-law Peta, a former Dancing with the Stars pro herself. It aired as Season 17, Episode 1. Her brief: the reception dress mattered more than the ceremony gown — the dress she would live in all night had to be fun, not poufy, a dress she could dance in.

Jenna Johnson trying the first dress, a white gown with an open back, seen in the mirror at Kleinfeld
The first dress set the bar — a white gown with an open back and a bow at the waist. (TLC)

The First Dress Set the Bar — and Ran Out of Time

Randy started with a white gown built for a dancer’s eye: high neckline, cap sleeves, a bodice thick with beading and pearls, an A-line tulle skirt, and an open back with a cutout and a bow at the waist. Jenna lit up in the mirror; the room loved the detail, the bright white, its movement. Her mom, the toughest critic in the room, liked it too, though the waist sagged and needed lifting. It became the benchmark. One problem: with two months to go, there was not enough time to order it the usual way.

The Tony Ward That Stopped the Room

Then Randy brought out a Tony Ward — also white, also high-necked, a turtleneck this time, cap sleeves, a bodice just as thick with beading and pearls, a slim belt, and a floor-length A-line tulle skirt that stayed light, never poufy. The room called it elegant, refined. Jenna did not need convincing: “I love the sleeves, I love the turtleneck. I feel spectacular in this.” She added, “I feel like this is what I would want to wear on my wedding day.” For a bride who dances for a living, that was the whole test — and the dress passed it. It carries the same spirit as Colette at Gownopia, an ivory A-line gown with a bodice built from thousands of pearls.

Randy Fenoli and the Kleinfeld team on the phone to Tony Ward in Paris
The midnight call to Paris — Randy and the Kleinfeld team on the phone to Tony Ward. (TLC)

The Midnight Call to Paris

But loving the dress was not enough — it still had to exist in time. So Randy and the Kleinfeld team called Tony Ward himself. He had just landed in Paris, where it was around 11 at night — and he said yes, he would make Jenna’s dress in four weeks. “Four weeks.” Where most gowns need months, four weeks was the difference between a dream and a disaster — one phone call placed at midnight in Paris.

‘Welcome to Plathville’: Ethan Plath Eager for Fatherhood – Is He Ready to Be a Stepdad with His New GF?YOU MAY LIKE‘Welcome to Plathville’: Ethan Plath Eager for Fatherhood – Is He Ready to Be a Stepdad with His New GF?

Planner or Procrastinator?

When Randy finally asked, “Jenna, are you saying yes to the dress?” she did not hesitate: “I’m saying yes to the dress!” Then, like only a Dancing with the Stars pro would, she twirled and danced while her mom cried. Her appointment splits fans down the middle. Team Reception Dress First says Jenna had it right: the dress you wear longest matters most, and a dancer knows a dress by its movement. Team Order Early says she gambled with the most photographed night of her life — one no from Paris, and no dress at all. Amy said yes after Randy rescued her Serena from a bankrupt salon; Caitlyn said yes to a $5,000 Reem Acra — but neither bet her wedding on a midnight phone call. So tell us: is the reception dress the real main event — or would you never leave it to the last two months?

Keep reading

More Say Yes to the Dress drama

Say Yes to the Dress

Network: TLC · Stream it on Max and discovery+ · Season now airing

&
JM
Jessica Monroe

Jessica covers Say Yes to the Dress and all things bridal for Remote & Tea — the dresses, the consultants and the Kleinfeld moments.

More from Say Yes to the Dress

See more ›