Emily Black walked into Kleinfeld Bridal with a $5,000-to-$10,000 budget, a St. Augustine, Florida wedding to plan — and her dad. Not just any dad: the man Randy Fenoli would soon nickname “Papazilla.” Emily calls herself a daddy’s princess. Her parents divorced when she was five, and her father raised her alone, playing both mum and dad. He was paying for the dress, and she knew it: she would not say yes until he loved it too.
Dress One: The $7,600 Crystal Ball Gown Dad Called a Dinner Dress
Consultant Allison pulled a Pnina Tornai ball gown: strapless sweetheart neckline, a bodice thick with crystals, a beaded belt, a floating tulle skirt. Emily loved it on sight. “I love shiny things,” she had said — and this one shone. Her dad did not agree. The skirt was not big enough. The waist needed to drop lower. To him it looked “like a dinner gown, and not a wedding dress.” Randy offered fixes — a petticoat for volume, a dropped waist for a fee — but the verdict was clear: dress one was not the one. Not for Papa.
Dress Two: The $7,800 Gown That Looked Like Underwear
Dress two fixed the skirt — bigger, fuller, the room approved. But the top was a lace corset, boning visible through the fabric, laces down the back, the waist dropped too low onto her hips. The room’s verdict was brutal: “Looks like underwear.” Alicia, in her entourage, summed up the split: the bottom looked good, the top had to be fixed. Emily still preferred dress one. Two Pnina gowns, two opposite problems — and a dad who had now rejected both.
Randy’s Crazy Fix: Wear Two Dresses at Once
That is when Randy did something wild. “We’re going to do something crazy,” he said — and had Allison layer the second gown right over the first in the fitting room, testing the combination on Emily’s body: the crystal bodice she loved, the bigger skirt the family loved, one waistline dropped just a little to lengthen the whole look. It worked so well that Kleinfeld built it for real — a one-of-a-kind custom Pnina Tornai ball gown, crystal-covered from bodice to hem, priced at $8,600. A dress like that does not come off a rack; it is built the way a hand-beaded ball gown like Céleste at Gownopia is built — sparkle as structure, not decoration.
The Verdict: Papazilla Finally Says Yes
Veil on, tiara on, Emily stepped out in the custom gown — and for a terrible second, even this one looked doomed to fail. Her dad was still stuck on the folds at the top. Then his face changed. “I love it.” “This is the dress.” “Emily, you look like a princess.” Randy asked the question, and Emily answered it: “I’m saying yes to the dress.” The man who had vetoed two gowns was suddenly all in — and the daddy’s princess finally felt like one.
YOU MAY LIKE‘Say Yes to the Dress’ star Monte Durham on how he overcame childhood bullying
Would You Let Your Dad Veto Your Dress?
Emily’s appointment splits fans straight down the middle. Team Papazilla says he raised her alone since she was five, he is paying, and he only wanted the best for his princess — he was right that dress one was too small and dress two’s top was wrong, and the $8,600 custom gown only exists because he refused to settle. Team Bride Decides says Emily loved dress one at $7,600 and nearly lost it to a veto; a grown bride with a two-year-old son should not need her dad’s permission to say yes. Shayla answered the same question with her hands instead of her eyes, and Leanna walked out over $7,000 rather than pay a price she did not believe in. So tell us: if your dad was paying — and vetoing — would you wait for his yes, or say yes to the dress you loved?
More Say Yes to the Dress drama
Say Yes to the DressShe Tried 100 Dresses, Found the One — Then Walked Out Over $7,000
Say Yes to the DressShe Couldn’t See Her Wedding Dress — So She Chose It by Touch as Randy Watched on an iPad
Say Yes to the DressHer Wedding Dress Burned in a California Wildfire — Then Kleinfeld Gave Her a New One
