Shayla Warkentin walked into Kleinfeld Bridal to shop for a wedding dress she would never see. Blind since a car crash at 15, she had one way to choose it: with her hands. Her fiancé, Tyler, was waiting at the end of the story.
Then came the twist: Randy Fenoli was not in the building. He joined on an iPad, held up by a member of Shayla’s entourage, while consultant Lisa ran the fitting. At one point Shayla nearly forgot he was there at all.
The Bride Who Shops by Touch
The years after the accident cost her more than vision. She assumed life would go back to normal, but lost many friends to what she called a communication barrier, and long believed no one would want to be with someone who could not see. Then she met her fiancé, Tyler, in a college class; he asked for her number under a pretext. On the days she does not feel beautiful, he makes her feel beautiful, she said. Her dress had to meet one standard: not a look, but a feeling — texture, shimmer, nothing plain.
The First Dress Her Mom Called Too Much
Dress one was fitted lace that flared from the knee: deep V, thin straps, sheer bodice scattered with lace appliqué, chiffon skirt. She liked what her hands found: simple, full of different textures. Her mom thought it was a bit much; Lisa suggested filling in the sheer bodice with more appliqué. Shayla felt good in it, but her mom was not sold.
Randy’s Dress Didn’t Feel Right
Dress two came from Randy himself: an A-line whose glittering skirt of sequins and rhinestones she could feel. Lisa adjusted the shoulders, and the room loved it. But Shayla did not feel it. She could hear the excitement in their voices, yet she did not feel beautiful — and that was the whole test. Randy, from the iPad, said what he always says: what matters most is that the bride feels beautiful in her dress. She could not see herself in the mirror; the feeling had to do all the work.
YOU MAY LIKEON SONG Brocarde lands two major TV gigs on First Dates and Say Yes To The DressThe Dress That Felt Like Everything
For dress three, she asked to touch the gown first — and loved its detail. A strapless sweetheart lace bodice over a light tulle skirt, ivory blushed with pale pink, its sparkle fading as it fell. “It’s everything.” It was the feeling she had struggled to describe, finally on her body — the same idea behind a hand-appliquéd lace A-line like Aurelia at Gownopia. Then Lisa asked about the veil. Shayla said yes to that too. The long veil fell down her back. She smiled: “I feel like a bride.” Her mom told her every little girl dreams of her wedding, that they had almost not made it to this moment — and that she was beautiful, and should never let anyone say otherwise. On the iPad, Randy gave a thumbs-up. Lisa asked the question; Shayla said yes, and the room erupted. She had found it.
Fans Are Still Split
Shayla’s appointment splits fans two ways at once. Team Trust Your Hands says she proved it: a dress is worn on the body, not hung on a wall. Team Trust Your Eyes answers that wedding photos last forever, and a bride who cannot see needs eyes she trusts. Then there is the Randy question. Team iPad says his thumbs-up from a screen counted exactly the same. Team In-Person says a fitting this personal needed Randy in the room, not on a tablet someone had to remember to hold up — the way Danielle’s family had him there when her $8,500 Pnina blew past the budget, and Eryka had him there after the fire. So tell us: would you say yes to a dress you had never seen — trusting only your hands and the people you love?
More Say Yes to the Dress drama
Say Yes to the DressHer Wedding Dress Burned in a California Wildfire — Then Kleinfeld Gave Her a New One
Say Yes to the DressHer 34J Bust Busted the Budget — Then Her Preacher Dad Said Yes to the $8,500 Pnina
Say Yes to the DressShe Went Dress Shopping With No Fiancé — Then She Tried On Her Mom’s Wedding Dress and Said Yes
